Crisis??? What Crisis??? Arsenal Can Play Good Defensive Chess
By DariusWhen Martin Atkinson started his 50 yard sprint towards the Arsenal penalty area just before half time in the game against West Ham, you could just smell disaster. His hand was in his pocket faster than he could blow the whistle and long before he even got to the incident.
It was like he had an itch and it needed to be scratched. To hell with what actually happened, a West Ham player going down in the box is good enough.
I suppose one way of looking at it is that we can thank Atkinson for the opportunity of creating another unforgiving test by reducing Arsenal to 10 men. Of course the boys passed with flying colours, so for what it’s worth, it was a good thing to face and overcome that adversity.
The flip side is that we get to miss the services of Vermaelen at St. Andrews this weekend. Someone in the legal team at Highbury House clearly feels it’s worth an appeal seeing as the referee was trigger happy.
You’d think that if Gazidis and his team can squeeze the UEFA chuffers and arm twist the European body to back down on Dudugate after the Crozilian’s 3 match ban, then the crisis laden FA is a walk in the park.
I’m one of those who think that perhaps Wenger should work on the basis that Vermaelen will be listening to Saturday’s game on Talk Sport radio from his gated mansion in Hertfordshire. Optimism about the appeal is good, but pragmatism is more useful.
This of course leaves the bemoaning Arsenal community with a sense of injustice as match officials seem to take matters in their own hands.
All season, you’d be hard pressed to find anyone who was comfortable with the fact that Silvestre and Senderos were Arsenal’s centre half understudies. I can’t remember the number of times I heard the quote ”we’re only an injury or suspension away from a defensive crisis”.
Well, we now have both an injury and a suspension to our first choice defensive pairing. The only argument I have is that I don’t think it constitutes a crisis.
For one, Wenger executed a masterstroke by bringing in Sol Campbell to plug in a hole until the end of the season. It was unrealistic to expect Arsenal to get any competent centre half willing to warm our bench in a world cup year, just in case something happens.
So do we have a crisis as is made out elsewhere on this wonderful blogosphere of ours?
I guess it depends on your disposition in life. For some people, the easier option is to take the view that anything that doesn’t work according to the script is a crisis.
Sometimes in life, we need to stop our propensity to look for negatives in any situation. The way to look at it is that we’ve been dealt a lousy hand and rather than moan, we need to use it to play a damn good game of cards and get us out from between a rock and a hard place.
I believe Wenger has several options in Arsenal’s defence, that stops this from getting anywhere near a crisis. Appealing Vermaelen’s red card is not a bad start.
My sense is that the options revolve around whether Sol Campbell and Thomas Vermaelen will be a more solid defensive pairing against Barcelona in 8 days time, or whether we will have to do with Alex Song and Vermaelen.
Campbell can’t physically play more than one game a week, but then again, who would have thought it was possible that he’d be still playing for Arsenal at 35.
Last Saturday, Wenger decided to use Song in defence, and I thought it was pleasing that Song took to the role like water off a duck’s back. It was like he’d been playing in Arsenal’s defence even before they built the Piccadilly railway line in 1902.
Song‘s performance against West Ham in defence makes it easier for Wenger to leave out Silvestre at Birmingham, if he chooses to play Sol Campbell. It’ll require another ’energizer’ bunny performance from Denilson, and a midfield of the Brazilian, Fabregas and Diaby are very capable of holding the fort at St. Andrews.
My sense is that since the stakes are very high, Song will be relieved off his midfield duties this weekend and asked to join Silvestre in defence on Saturday against Birmingham.
I suppose one way to think about this is to ask yourself whether you’d be more comfortable with Messi running at Silvestre with the ball or whether Campbell is a better bet. It’s the lesser of two evils and someone, glad it’s not me, has to make a decision about what risk we can live with.
The alternative is to play Song and Vermaelen in defence against Barca, but I think Song will be more useful indulging in the dark arts of the defensive midfielder in the game against Barca.
I get the sense that Barcelona are cursing the Champions league quarter final draw against Arsenal. Contrary to popular belief, Arsenal’s game has a lot of respect across Europe, and the game a week on Wednesday will be one of those where the team that wins is the team that has the balls to score more goals.
Before we get excited about the football spectacle though, there’s a small matter of navigating past the unsavoury characters at St. Andrews on Saturday.
We know what happened last time, and Arsenal’s team talk is already done.


Tue 13th September 2011; 19:45, Dortmund
I think it best to play song back there again the brummies. Wtih denilson and diaby holding we should be ‘alright’. However I can’t stop biting my nails at the prospect of campbell/silvestre having to defend against barcelona’s attact, namely, messi. This could be our undoing, but as aforementioned, the game resolve would be who wants to score more goals.
I also hope AA23 brings it in that game, known for his outspokenness for wanting to play the big games this is his chance to show he really wants this. None of that passive-moment-of maybe some brillinace-coz i scored 4 goals at anfield crap.
Hopefully B52 brings his shooting boots.
I think the suspension gives us an opportunity to rest TV, he’s one Arsenal player that has played everyone of the premiership games this season.
And TV will be available for the Barca game, the suspension is only for the EPL.
Please tell me why Upson got away with out a card for handling inside the box that led to our penalty. Had he been shown a yellow that would have led to a RED.
But as you say Darius, our boys continue to pass the test with flying colours.
At this point in time, I feel that we should focus squarely on the Birmingham game. A win is a must there. Song can do a good job in defence there, our midfield is fine. The question is, do we use Sol for Birmingham alongside Song or do we use Silvestre? That for me is a headache. We must not over use Sol. There are still six other Premiership games where we may need him more.
I think we lose something too valuable from our midfield if we drop Diaby. By adding Song into defence, it allows us to get him, Diaby, Denislon, and cesc on the pitch together. I think we should play like that against Barca.
Darius,
I would like to second Arsenehollis. The St. Andrews draw is a must win and so is the Emirates Barca tie. I believe Song can do a very good job at CB, and therefore playing Song and Campbell at St. Andrews would be to strengthen his abilities / lessons as a CB which should help him during the Emirates Barca tie. Also, it would increase our chances of winning the tie (remember they have not lost at St. Andrews for quite a long period), the Baggies are not going to be easy. You said that and I quote “I suppose one way to think about this is to ask yourself whether you’d be more comfortable with Messi running at Silvestre with the ball or whether Campbell is a better bet.” I feel uncomfortable at Messi running at both i.e. Sylverstre and Campbell, I hope I am not alone here. You state it as an opportunity for Arsene and Arsenal to play a defensive chess; so, why not take the opportunity for Song to continue his education at CB in preparation for Barca, and for the Denilson / Diaby / Cesc to continue honing their understanding, and for Denilson to continue improving his sharpness in the DM position? There is talk of Gallas returning for Barca at the Emirates but I would think it is premature. Even if he begins kicking a ball, he will not be match sharp before the Emirates tie given the length of time he’s been out. I know Wenger works miracles with returning players, but I still cannot see Gallas being fully involved at the emirates. I have no problem with the Denilson / Diaby / Cesc combo in MF and Song at CB during the Barca tie at Emirates, but cannot trust Campbell, despite his experience, against such fleet-footed opponents. I remember his display during the Porto tie at the Emirates, although overall was steady, it was not a particularly comfortable watching. Now though it will be the mercurial Inniesta and Messi facing him. There is no problem for him shutting out Henry or Ibrahimovich though.
I would also like to touch base on the TV5 appeal being dismissed. Yes, the Arsenal fans have the right to feel aggrieved as it was, quite frankly, not a foul. Even more so if dangerous fouls like the G. Neville display at OT on Sunday, which left Max Rodriguez face looking like he’s been in a train accident, are left unpunished. Surprisingly not even a foul was called. Even worse it has received no attention at all anywhere, not the MOTD, not the papers, no anyone, not even by you Darius! Did I miss something??
Another one here for the Silvestre and song partnership at st andrews. Then Song and Vermealen for Barca. As you say this needen’t be a crisis Darius. That said I really am hoping for a full season with Djourou.